Fishing research in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay
30 studies in Anglrithm's evidence library were done in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, in the Southwest Gulf region. 19 of them show their findings here, each with where and when it was done, its sample where it states one, and how we read it; the other 11 were read only in their abstract and are listed by citation with their numbers withheld. Where research was done, not where fish are.
The water body
- Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay
- NOAA grading station
Library built Nov 1, 2026. A study is placed by the places its own text names; one that names a wider region only, or water outside South Florida, is not placed on any water body.
What was studied here
30 studies: 19 show their findings, 11 were read in the abstract only. The 10 that state their years span 1988 to 2022. 4 studies on spawning, placed at the water body and never at a site. 5 followed tagged or tracked fish; no receiver or tag point is shown.
By factor
- Habitat6
- Salinity5
- Spawning4
- Season3
- Hurricanes and storms3
- Catch and release3
- Fronts and edges1
- Dissolved oxygen1
- Water clarity1
- Runoff and freshwater flow1
- Barometric pressure1
- Other1
A study about several fish counts once for each fish it speaks to; each study has one factor.
The findings
Season
FWC seines catch newly settled redfish, 40 mm or smaller, mainly September to March, the peak recruitment season in Florida estuaries.
FWC Fisheries-Independent Monitoring builds its young-of-the-year red drum index from fish 40 mm SL or smaller caught in 21.3-m seines during the peak recruitment season, September-March, in Tampa Bay, Charlotte Harbor, the Indian River Lagoon and northern estuaries. Subadult indices (300 mm SL and larger) use year-round 183-m haul seines.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, agency document
Addis 2020Florida's tarpon fishery is seasonal: most fish are caught May through July, though some are caught in every month.
Study of 1,469 South Florida tarpon (1988-1993). Background: most Florida tarpon are caught May-July, some in all months; larval distributions suggest offshore spawning May-August. Large fish came mainly from the Keys and Boca Grande Pass. Otolith ages reached 55 years; growth was rapid to about 12 years.
Studied in the Florida Keys, Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 1988 to 1993, field study, full text read
Crabtree et al. 1995The Keys hold Florida's main tarpon concentration; some fish stay all year, but adults gather in greatest numbers April through August, often around bridges.
Field guide account: tarpon range the Atlantic coast and Panhandle in summer, with the Keys as the center of abundance. Some fish are present year round, but adult accumulations peak April-August, visible from Overseas Highway bridges. A similar run occurs at Boca Grande Pass at the mouth of Charlotte Harbor. Indian River Lagoon mosquito impoundments hold many juveniles.
Studied in the Florida Keys, Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, review, full text read
Snyder & Burgess 2016
Spawning
Everglades river snook vary more from year to year in leaving for spawning, likely tied to freshwater flow.
Acoustic tracking of snook in the Shark River compared with a published Caloosahatchee study. Similar shares of fish stayed in the river through spawning season (presumed skipped spawning), but Shark River fish varied more between years, likely with freshwater flow and floodplain flooding, spent less time outside the river, and more left without returning.
Studied in the Everglades, Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, field study, full text re-read Oct 16, 2026
Boucek et al. 2019Young adult redfish return to spawn in nearshore water off the estuary where they grew up.
20 subadult red drum tagged in Tampa Bay (2012) and 20 in Charlotte Harbor (2013), tracked 3 years. 74% of Tampa Bay fish reached nearshore adult habitat the year tagged, versus 24% from Charlotte Harbor (65% the next year). Fish from both returned to spawn off their home estuary.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, field study, full text re-read Oct 16, 2026
Walters Burnsed et al. 2020
Habitat
Juvenile permit use sandy estuary beaches in lower Charlotte Harbor, mainly June to December.
Ten years (1991-2000) of seine data: juvenile permit (15-360 mm SL) most abundant along unvegetated sandy beaches in the lower estuary, at densities similar to or higher than exposed coastal beaches. Small juveniles under 100 mm present almost only June-December.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 1991 to 2000, field study, full text re-read Oct 18, 2026
Adams & Blewett 2004Young gag settle in Charlotte Harbor in April and May, use shallow seagrass shoals and mangrove shores near the passes, and leave October to December.
FWC seines, 1996-2002: 738 juvenile gag (30-489 mm SL), 95% in Gasparilla and Pine Island sounds, mostly under 3.3 m near Gasparilla and Boca Grande passes. Settlers arrived April-May; numbers peaked in September and fell October-December as fish shifted deeper. Most were on seagrass-covered shoals or mangrove shores. Elsewhere, fall cold fronts are thought to trigger egress.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 1996 to 2002, 738 juvenile gag caught, field study, full text read
Casey et al. 2005Young mutton snapper in Florida estuaries are caught mainly in the southern Indian River Lagoon, recruiting August-November; they are rare in Gulf estuaries.
FWC FIM 183-m seine, 1997-2022: 2,412 muttons in the southern Indian River Lagoon and 418 in the northern lagoon, almost all from its southern zone; only 55 in Charlotte Harbor, 1 each in Apalachicola and Northeast Florida, none in Cedar Key. Fish 34-331 mm SL; peak recruitment August-November. Lows in 2016 and 2019 followed seagrass loss and hurricanes.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 1997 to 2022, survey, agency document
Klimek et al. 2023Shallow coastal ponds ringed by salt marsh and overhanging mangroves are nurseries for juvenile snook, with juvenile tarpon nearby.
Seasonal seining August 2019 to May 2022 in 22 coastal ponds on the Cape Haze peninsula (651 net sets, 61,702 fish and selected invertebrates). Juvenile snook were most abundant in large, shallow ponds bordered by salt marsh, salterns and overhanging mangroves. Juvenile tarpon overlapped with snook but also used ponds farther inland.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 2019 to 2022, field study, full text re-read Oct 16, 2026
Saari et al. 2025Small juvenile redfish in Charlotte Harbor turned up mainly in the low-salinity lower Peace and Myakka rivers, not on the harbor's big seagrass beds.
FWC FIM seine samples, fall (September-November) 1997-2000: juvenile red drum (gear targets 15-100 mm SL) occurred in 19% of samples and were most likely in the lower Peace and Myakka rivers, at low-salinity sites with little or no seagrass, near needlerush marsh and also seawall and rubble shores. The model fit significantly but predicted independent samples poorly.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 1997 to 2000, field study, full text read
Whaley et al. 2007
Fronts and edges
For about three days after a cold front, dead-end canals stay warmest; snook have little time to find warm water.
Loggers in estuary, river and canal habitats (winters 2008-2010) showed similar temperatures except for about 3 days after cold fronts, when differences reached up to 2 C and canals were warmest and most stable. In January 2010 dead snook were found at 43 sites, 26 of them kills of 100-2,000 fish.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 2008 to 2010, field study, full text re-read Oct 18, 2026
Blewett & Stevens 2014
Salinity
Young bull sharks avoid water fresher than about 7 PSU and move upriver when the river runs saltier.
56 young bull sharks tracked up to 460 days in the Caloosahatchee. They avoided salinity under 7 and favored 7 to at least 20 (switch point 8 for all years). Mean river position tracked salinity; at flows above 113 m3 per second they stayed near the mouth, but spread through the river below 57. Temperature mattered little.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 2003 to 2005, 56 sharks tracked, field study, full text read
Heupel & Simpfendorfer 2008Juvenile spotted seatrout abundance peaks near 17 to 20 ppt salinity and rises with warmth up to about 28 C.
GAMs on FWC seine data from three Florida estuaries: unimodal salinity effect peaking at 20 ppt (IRL), 17 ppt (Tampa Bay), 18 ppt (Charlotte Harbor). Abundance increased with temperature to 28 C, then declined in IRL, kept rising in TB, flat in CH. Seagrass and sand-mud bottoms were most productive.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, model study, full text read
Kupschus 2003In the lower Peace River and Charlotte Harbor, resident fish hold to fixed salinity bands, while red drum shift salinity zones between seasons.
Fisheries-independent monitoring 1996-2013 used to build seasonal habitat suitability maps for 32 estuarine life stages. Six estuarine residents kept similar preferred salinity ranges across seasons, expanding geographically in the summer wet season as inflow rose. Estuarine-transient red drum and spot used different salinity ranges between seasons.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 1996 to 2013, model study, full text re-read Oct 18, 2026
Rubec et al. 2019
Runoff and freshwater flow
In wet years, snook move up rivers in fall to feed on prey draining off floodplains; flow predicts snook abundance there.
Electrofishing 2005 and 2007-2013 in the Peace River: in average or wetter years, snook abundance rose up to 3-fold and body condition 1.2-fold from summer high water to fall falling water. Mean annual abundance tracked mean annual flow (R2 0.88); condition tracked days above a river-level threshold (R2 0.70). No rise in a drought year.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, 2005 to 2013, field study, full text re-read Oct 17, 2026
Blewett et al. 2017
Barometric pressure
Juvenile tarpon leave isolated mangrove ponds on low pressure and high water; distant ponds need tropical storm flooding to let them out.
Acoustic telemetry of juvenile tarpon in coastal ponds on the Cape Haze peninsula. Emigration rose with low barometric pressure, high water level and larger body size. Ponds near tidal creeks drained fish on summer king tides; ponds farther inland needed tropical cyclone conditions. Fish later appeared at river mouths about 30 km up-estuary. Pressure effect not given as a threshold.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, field study, full text re-read Oct 16, 2026
Bunting et al. 2024
Catch and release
Caloosahatchee estuary health is best when S-79 flows mostly sit at 450-800 cfs; months above 2,800 cfs push freshwater toward Shell Point.
CERP RECOVER performance measure (revised 2007): about 75% of S-79 flows should be 450-800 cfs and the rest 800-2,800 cfs. Mean monthly flows over 2,800 cfs make more than half the estuary above Shell Point fresh; over 4,500 cfs degrade San Carlos Bay. Adult oysters die below 3 ppt, reached when S-79 exceeds 4,000 cfs.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, agency document
RECOVER 2007Current RECOVER envelope: S-79 at 750-2,100 cfs (14-day average) is optimum; above 2,600 cfs is damaging.
SCCF weekly condition reports apply the RECOVER 2020 envelope to the S-79 14-day moving average: optimum 750-2,100 cfs, damaging above 2,600 cfs. Example: October 2025, 14-day mean 1,059 cfs, optimum for 11 days after 36 days damaging. The original RECOVER 2020 document was not retrieved here.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, agency document
Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation 2025
Other
Lee County estuaries use annual-mean chlorophyll limits near 4 to 6.5 ug/L; tidal rivers allow up to about 12.6.
Criteria (annual arithmetic means unless stated): Pine Island Sound chlorophyll 6.5 ug/L, TN 0.57, TP 0.06 mg/L; San Carlos Bay 3.7 ug/L long-term average; Estero Bay 5.9 ug/L; Matlacha Pass 6.1; Charlotte Harbor proper 6.1; Lower, Middle, Upper Caloosahatchee 5.6, 6.5, 4.2 ug/L long-term averages; Tidal Peace River 12.6.
Studied in Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay, agency document
Florida Department of Environmental Protection 2016
Each finding in our own words, with where and when the study was done, its sample where it states one, how it was done and how we read it, and its DOI or agency link. Guidance beside the score, never in it.
Read in the abstract only
- Lowerre-Barbieri et al. 2016, Assessing reproductive behavior important to fisheries management: a case study with red drum, Sciaenops ocellatus. Spawning; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Trotter et al. 2012, Migrations of Common Snook from a Tidal River with Implications for Skipped Spawning. Spawning; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Winner et al. 2010, Relative Abundance and Distribution of Common Snook along Shoreline Habitats of Florida Estuaries. Habitat; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Qiu & Wan 2013, Time series modeling and prediction of salinity in the Caloosahatchee River Estuary. Salinity; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Rubec et al. 2021, Habitat suitability modeling and mapping to assess the influence of freshwater withdrawals on spatial distributions and population numbers of estuarine species in the lower Peace River and Charlotte Harbor, Florida. Salinity; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Stevens et al. 2006, Short-term effects of a low dissolved oxygen event on estuarine fish assemblages following the passage of hurricane Charley. Dissolved oxygen; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Wang et al. 2012, Characterization of turbidity in Florida's Lake Okeechobee and Caloosahatchee and St. Lucie estuaries using MODIS-Aqua measurements. Water clarity; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Chen & Li 2026, Discerning drivers of a coastal Karenia brevis bloom after Hurricane Ian (2022) on the West Florida Shelf. Hurricanes and storms; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Greenwood et al. 2006, Effects of the 2004 hurricanes on the fish assemblages in two proximate southwest Florida estuaries: change in the context of interannual variability. Hurricanes and storms; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Locascio & Mann 2005, Effects of Hurricane Charley on fish chorusing. Hurricanes and storms; abstract read, numbers withheld.
- Medina et al. 2022, Nitrogen-enriched discharges from a highly managed watershed intensify red tide (Karenia brevis) blooms in southwest Florida. Catch and release; abstract read, numbers withheld.
Each waits for a full-text read before any of its numbers shows, in the app or here.
Research cited
Research cited: Bonefish & Tarpon Trust; FIU Florida Coastal Everglades LTER and Coastal Fisheries Lab. Cited, not endorsed.
Where the forecasts are graded
Anglrithm grades its forecasts against what NOAA instruments measured, at 12 stations off South Florida. Each record below names the stations it reads; each station names what it grades there, how much has been scored, over which dates, and the model with the lowest error there one day ahead, with that error and its sample.
- The scoreboard: 137,452 station-hours at 8 stations (Virginia Key, Lake Worth Pier, Long Key, Sombrero Key, Sand Key, Key West, Hollywood Beach, Satan Shoal), January 1, 2024 to August 27, 2026.
- Seas, the moving record: 12,888 paired hours at 3 stations (Fort Pierce, Hollywood Beach, Satan Shoal), October 10, 2026 to November 15, 2026.
- The reliability record: 29,528 pairs at 6 stations (Virginia Key, Lake Worth Pier, Long Key, Sombrero Key, Sand Key, Key West), October 9, 2026 to November 15, 2026.
- The satellite water check: 241 station-days at 9 stations (Virginia Key, Lake Worth Pier, Key West, Hollywood Beach, Fort Pierce, Satan Shoal, WFS Central, WFS South, Fort Myers), October 17, 2026 to November 15, 2026.
- NOAA grading station
The station in or beside the map of Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay above:
- Fort MyersNOAA FMRF1
- The satellite water check: the satellite water temperature (JPL MUR) against the station thermometer. 29 days scored, October 17, 2026 to November 15, 2026. Mean absolute error here 1.9 °F.
The other 11 stations are listed with their records on the accuracy page.
Accuracy is never gated. Every figure is from the record's own file as this page was built.
More research and the water
Charlotte Harbor and Estero Bay sits in the Southwest Gulf region page. The fish studied here each have a page with their water band and season: Snook, Redfish, Tarpon and Grouper, and the rest above. Every study in the library, wherever it was done, is on the science page.
The skill-weighted score
ProEvery model weighted by its measured error at the NOAA weather station nearest your spot, with its bias removed.
Pro weights each forecast model by its measured error at the NOAA weather station nearest your spot. This page shows where research was done, not where fish are.
A free account scores your home spot hour by hour today and tomorrow, logs every catch, and emails you a Sick Day when your home spot lines up, once a week at most.
Create a free accountDisplay only, not for navigation. Every figure here names its source; check the NWS marine forecast and the posted rules before you leave the dock.