Fishing research in the Dry Tortugas

17 studies in Anglrithm's evidence library were done in the Dry Tortugas, in the Florida Keys and Florida Bay region. 11 of them show their findings here, each with where and when it was done, its sample where it states one, and how we read it; the other 6 were read only in their abstract and are listed by citation with their numbers withheld. Where research was done, not where fish are.

The water body

Florida KeysEvergladesDry TortugasSand Key, NOAA SANF1Key West, NOAA KYWF1Satan Shoal, NOAA 42095
Where research was done, not where fish are. The outline is the Dry Tortugas National Park boundary (NPS). Coastline: NOAA NGS CUSP. Display only, not for navigation and not a legal boundary.
  • Dry Tortugas
  • Other water bodies with a research page
  • NOAA grading station

Library built Nov 1, 2026. A study is placed by the places its own text names; one that names a wider region only, or water outside South Florida, is not placed on any water body.

What was studied here

17 studies: 11 show their findings, 6 were read in the abstract only. The 6 that state their years span 1997 to 2022. 4 followed tagged or tracked fish; no receiver or tag point is shown.

By fish

By factor

  • Habitat9
  • Depth3
  • Other2
  • Current1
  • Water clarity1
  • Light1

A study about several fish counts once for each fish it speaks to; each study has one factor.

The findings

Habitat

  • Tagged yellowtail use about 4 square km of reef; a tracked gray snapper made long nightly migrations.

    Acoustic array: mean home range red grouper 2.09 km2 (n=28, 45-66 cm), yellowtail 4.17 km2 (n=5), black grouper 1.44 km2 (n=2), mutton 7.64 km2 (n=1). Red grouper and yellowtail moved 700-900 m; black grouper moved little; one gray snapper made long nocturnal migrations.

    Studied in the Dry Tortugas, field study, full text re-read Oct 17, 2026

    Farmer & Ault 2011
  • Tagged groupers use about 2-4 square km and mutton snapper about 6-8 square km of reef.

    Individual-based models from multi-year acoustic tracking: upper-bound home ranges red grouper 2.28 km2 (MCP), 3.60 (kernel); black grouper 2.06 and 3.93; mutton snapper 7.72 and 6.16. Short studies underestimate home range.

    Studied in the Dry Tortugas, model study, full text re-read Oct 17, 2026

    Farmer & Ault 2014
  • Southeast Florida reefs hold fewer species and fewer young target fish than protected reference reefs; adult target fish are scarce in the Keys too.

    Diver surveys 2016-2018 on reefs shallower than 33 m, compared with a Dry Tortugas reference area. Richness and juvenile target density were lower in SE Florida; adult target density was lower in the Keys and SE Florida (P below 0.001). Mean lengths fell short for 4 of 10 species in the Keys, 4 of 9 in SE Florida.

    Studied in the Florida Keys, the Dry Tortugas, 2016 to 2018, field study, full text read

    Grove et al. 2024
  • Adult yellowtail snapper are most often found on high-relief reef and the deeper forereef; juveniles use patch reefs.

    RVC 1999-2016 (hard bottom under 30 m). Adults (19 cm FL and up) had highest occurrence on high-relief reef and deep forereef strata; juveniles more on inshore to offshore patch reefs. The January 2010 cold event coincided with a drop in occurrence. Tortugas held more adults than the Keys.

    Studied in the Florida Keys, the Dry Tortugas, 1999 to 2016, agency document

    Herbig et al. 2019
  • Tagged yellowtail snapper kept small home ranges, favored reef edges, and were more often absent in summer and at dusk or night.

    Fifteen yellowtail snapper tracked 2008 to 2009 on 86 acoustic receivers for 1 to 427 days. Six fish showed high site fidelity (mean 58.4 percent). Estimated minimum home range averaged 5.45 km2. Fish preferred reef edge habitat and were more likely absent in summer and at dusk and night. Small sample.

    Studied in the Dry Tortugas, 2008 to 2009, 15 fish tracked, field study, full text re-read Oct 16, 2026

    Herbig et al. 2019
  • SE Florida shallow reefs hold far fewer yellowtail, gray snapper and hogfish than Keys reefs; mutton snapper are similar.

    1,360 sites, 0-33 m, May-Oct 2012-2016. Percent occurrence SE Florida vs Keys vs Tortugas: yellowtail 27.9 vs 64.6 vs 80.5; gray snapper 9.3 vs 23.9 vs 19.0; hogfish 23.5 vs 70.3 vs 45.7; mutton 30.1 vs 24.7 vs 39.3. Depth (10 m split), reef type, relief and location drove assemblages.

    Studied in the Florida Keys, the Dry Tortugas, 2012 to 2016, agency document

    Kilfoyle et al. 2017
  • Mutton snapper on SE Florida reefs are mostly sub-adult; median sizes run larger in the Keys and larger again in the Dry Tortugas.

    Diver-estimated median sizes from RVC: SE Florida 37 cm TL (about 10% at or above 50% maturity size), Florida Keys 44.4 cm (about 51%), Dry Tortugas 52 cm (about 77%). Length at 50% maturity 42.2 cm TL.

    Studied in the Florida Keys, the Dry Tortugas, agency document

    Muller & Allen 2023

Depth

  • Winter kings around south Florida are mostly over the continental shelf; the Atlantic share of landings fell from southeast to southwest Florida.

    Otolith shape study of winter landings, December-March 2001-02 and 2002-03, in three zones: southwest Florida near the Dry Tortugas, the Keys (charter boats south of Islamorada) and southeast Florida. The Atlantic share ranged from 14.5% (southwest, females) to 82.8% (southeast, females), with confidence limits near plus or minus 20%. Fish are mostly over the shelf inside 200 m.

    Studied in the Florida Keys, the Dry Tortugas, field study, full text read

    Clardy et al. 2008
  • On Keys reefs, mutton snapper are seen more often at deeper, more seaward stations than on shallow patch reefs.

    FWC analysis of NOAA/UM Reef Visual Census (RVC, stations to 33 m). Keys: mutton seen at 19% of 10,135 stations; mean depth where seen 11.3 m vs 8.0 m where absent. SE Florida: seen at 35% of 3,530 stations (median station depth 16 m). Dry Tortugas: 30% of stations, no depth effect.

    Studied in the Florida Keys, the Dry Tortugas, 1997 to 2022, agency document

    Muller & Allen 2023
  • Gray snapper are common on Keys reefs to 30 m, but larger adults also live deeper than divers survey.

    Gray snapper seen at 22.5% of 13,607 RVC stations (1997-2018). Median diver-estimated size 24 cm TL; 29% at or above 30.5 cm. Depth category, habitat and reef zone predicted presence. Author used dome selectivity because the species ranges deeper than the 30 m survey limit. Counts of 350-1,605 fish likely spawning aggregations.

    Studied in the Florida Keys, the Dry Tortugas, 1997 to 2018, agency document

    Muller 2022

Light

  • Yellowtail feed by day and night; tagged adults appear to forage over hard bottom and seagrass after dusk, returning to the reef edge at dawn.

    SEDAR 64 review: yellowtail feed above the bottom, not only at night; reports differ on whether feeding is mainly by day or night. Herbig et al. (2019a) suggested tagged adults forage over hard bottom, reef and seagrass from dusk through the night, returning at dawn to forage along the reef edge. Tagged fish showed fewer detections at night.

    Studied in the Dry Tortugas, agency document

    SEDAR 2020

Each finding in our own words, with where and when the study was done, its sample where it states one, how it was done and how we read it, and its DOI or agency link. Guidance beside the score, never in it.

Read in the abstract only

  • Ault et al. 2013, Assessing coral reef fish population and community changes in response to marine reserves in the Dry Tortugas, Florida, USA. Habitat; abstract read, numbers withheld.
  • Huntington et al. 2017, Facilitation in Caribbean coral reefs: high densities of staghorn coral foster greater coral condition and reef fish composition. Habitat; abstract read, numbers withheld.
  • Lee et al. 1995, Florida Current meanders and gyre formation in the southern Straits of Florida. Current; abstract read, numbers withheld.
  • Zepp et al. 2008, Spatial and temporal variability of solar ultraviolet exposure of coral assemblages in the Florida Keys: importance of colored dissolved organic matter. Water clarity; abstract read, numbers withheld.
  • Keller et al. 2024, The Reef Visual Census: a review of an essential long- term data source for reef-fish management in Florida. Other; abstract read, numbers withheld.
  • Smith et al. 2011, Multispecies survey design for assessing reef-fish stocks, spatially explicit management performance, and ecosystem condition. Other; abstract read, numbers withheld.

Each waits for a full-text read before any of its numbers shows, in the app or here.

Where the forecasts are graded

Anglrithm grades its forecasts against what NOAA instruments measured, at 12 stations off South Florida. Each record below names the stations it reads; each station names what it grades there, how much has been scored, over which dates, and the model with the lowest error there one day ahead, with that error and its sample.

  • The scoreboard: 137,452 station-hours at 8 stations (Virginia Key, Lake Worth Pier, Long Key, Sombrero Key, Sand Key, Key West, Hollywood Beach, Satan Shoal), January 1, 2024 to August 27, 2026.
  • Seas, the moving record: 12,888 paired hours at 3 stations (Fort Pierce, Hollywood Beach, Satan Shoal), October 10, 2026 to November 15, 2026.
  • The reliability record: 29,528 pairs at 6 stations (Virginia Key, Lake Worth Pier, Long Key, Sombrero Key, Sand Key, Key West), October 9, 2026 to November 15, 2026.
  • The satellite water check: 241 station-days at 9 stations (Virginia Key, Lake Worth Pier, Key West, Hollywood Beach, Fort Pierce, Satan Shoal, WFS Central, WFS South, Fort Myers), October 17, 2026 to November 15, 2026.
Virginia Key, NOAA VAKF1Lake Worth Pier, NOAA LKWF1Long Key, NOAA LONF1Sombrero Key, NOAA SMKF1Sand Key, NOAA SANF1Key West, NOAA KYWF1Hollywood Beach, NOAA 41122Satan Shoal, NOAA 42095Fort Pierce, NOAA 41114WFS Central, NOAA 42013WFS South, NOAA 42023Fort Myers, NOAA FMRF1
Station positions: NOAA's published station metadata. Coastline: NOAA NGS CUSP. Display only, not for navigation.
  • NOAA grading station

The 3 stations in or beside the map of the Dry Tortugas above:

  • Sand KeyNOAA SANF1
    • The scoreboard: wind speed, gust, wind direction, pressure and air temperature from 7 weather models in the scored archive. 22,754 hours scored, January 1, 2024 to August 27, 2026. Lowest error here one day ahead: NBM, 2.0 kt mean absolute error over 16,262 hours.
    • The reliability record: how many of the 7 weather models kept the wind at or under each limit, against the wind measured. 29,528 pairs across its 6 stations together, October 9, 2026 to November 15, 2026.

    NDBC station page

  • Key WestNOAA KYWF1
    • The scoreboard: wind speed, gust, wind direction, pressure and air temperature from 7 weather models in the scored archive. 22,066 hours scored, January 1, 2024 to August 27, 2026. Lowest error here one day ahead: GFS, 2.5 kt mean absolute error over 22,066 hours.
    • The reliability record: how many of the 7 weather models kept the wind at or under each limit, against the wind measured. 29,528 pairs across its 6 stations together, October 9, 2026 to November 15, 2026.
    • The satellite water check: the satellite water temperature (JPL MUR) against the station thermometer. 29 days scored, October 17, 2026 to November 15, 2026. Mean absolute error here 0.8 °F.

    NDBC station page · CO-OPS station page

  • Satan ShoalNOAA 42095
    • The scoreboard: wave height and wave period from 3 wave models in the scored archive. 6,657 hours scored, January 1, 2024 to August 27, 2026. Lowest error here one day ahead: ECMWF WAM, 0.5 ft mean absolute error over 6,657 hours.
    • Seas, the moving record: wave height from 4 wave models, snapshot daily. 4,280 hours scored, October 10, 2026 to November 15, 2026. Lowest error here one day ahead: ECMWF WAM, 0.4 ft mean absolute error over 648 hours.
    • The satellite water check: the satellite water temperature (JPL MUR) against the station thermometer. 30 days scored, October 17, 2026 to November 15, 2026. Mean absolute error here 0.4 °F.

    NDBC station page

The other 9 stations are listed with their records on the accuracy page.

Accuracy is never gated. Every figure is from the record's own file as this page was built.

More research and the water

The Dry Tortugas sits in the Florida Keys and Florida Bay region page. The fish studied here each have a page with their water band and season: Mutton Snapper, Yellowtail, Grouper and Kingfish. Every study in the library, wherever it was done, is on the science page.

The skill-weighted score

Pro

Every model weighted by its measured error at the NOAA weather station nearest your spot, with its bias removed.

Pro weights each forecast model by its measured error at the NOAA weather station nearest your spot. This page shows where research was done, not where fish are.

See what Free and Pro include

A free account scores your home spot hour by hour today and tomorrow, logs every catch, and emails you a Sick Day when your home spot lines up, once a week at most.

Create a free account

Display only, not for navigation. Every figure here names its source; check the NWS marine forecast and the posted rules before you leave the dock.